Candidate Identity Verification: A Guide for Hiring Consultants
By Keara Garrett. Last updated .
The short answer
Candidate identity verification, also called employment identity verification, confirms that the person who applies, interviews and starts work is a real person who is who they claim to be. For remote consultant and contractor roles, a single check at the start is not enough. Confirm identity early, then confirm it is the same person at each step until their first day.
This guide is for HR, talent acquisition, procurement and technology leaders hiring AI, data and tech consultants in Canada and the US. It covers what identity fraud looks like, where to check, what a good check includes, and what to do when something does not add up.
What does identity fraud look like when hiring consultants?
Identity fraud in hiring is any case where the person behind an application is not the person on paper. It is different from resume embellishment. An inflated job title is a resume problem. A different human doing the work is an identity problem.
The common patterns are:
- Stolen identity. Someone applies using a real person's name, documents and work history.
- Synthetic identity. A profile is built from a mix of real and invented details, so no single real person stands behind it.
- Impersonation in interviews. A skilled stand-in, or a deepfake, takes the interview for the real applicant. Our guide to proxy interview detection covers this in depth.
- Swap after the offer. The person who interviewed is not the person who logs in on day one.
- Hidden location. The worker is somewhere other than where they claim, often to get around sanctions or work eligibility rules.
For consultants, there is a related risk: a firm presents one senior person and then staffs the work with someone else. That is a vendor problem more than an identity problem. Our guide to stopping consultant bait and switch covers it.
Why are remote tech roles the main target?
Remote tech roles pay well, rarely require an in-person meeting, and often come with access to systems and data. That combination makes them worth faking.
The FBI flagged this pattern in June 2022. Its Internet Crime Complaint Center reported a rise in complaints about deepfakes and stolen personal information being used to apply for remote roles in IT, programming, database and software work. Some of those roles included access to customer data, financial data and corporate databases. In some cases, pre-employment background checks found that the details an applicant gave belonged to someone else. (FBI IC3, 2022)
The largest documented cases involve North Korean IT workers. In June 2025, the US Department of Justice announced coordinated actions against these schemes. According to the court documents, North Korean workers used stolen and fake identities to get remote IT jobs at more than 100 US companies. In one indictment, prosecutors allege the scheme compromised the identities of more than 80 US people and caused at least $3 million in losses to victim companies. (US Department of Justice, 2025)
The same release describes how the schemes worked. US-based helpers received company laptops at their homes, so the workers appeared to be local. Overseas workers then logged in remotely. Some gained access to sensitive data, including export-controlled technical data at a defense contractor. These are allegations in court documents, not convictions.
The lesson for buyers is simple. A laptop shipping address, a US phone number and a polished profile do not prove who is doing the work. Remote hiring identity verification has to look past those surface signals.
How common is candidate identity fraud?
No one has a reliable count of how many hires involve a false identity. Most figures come from surveys, and many come from vendors who sell screening tools. Read every number with that in mind, including the ones below.
The most useful figures come from Gartner, published in July 2025 (Gartner, 2025):
- In a survey of 3,000 job candidates, 6% admitted to interview fraud. That means either posing as someone else or having someone else pose as them in an interview. This is self-reported, so the real figure could be higher.
- Gartner predicts that by 2028, one in four candidate profiles worldwide will be fake. This is a forecast about profiles, not a count of people hired today.
- In a separate survey of 3,290 candidates, 39% said they used AI during the application process, most often to write resume text. Using AI to polish a resume is not identity fraud. It does mean a well-written profile tells you less than it used to.
Gartner's own advice is to build a fraud strategy in layers. That includes telling candidates your standards up front, using the assessment process to surface fraud, and adding identity checks to recruiting systems rather than relying on interviewers to spot problems.
When should candidate identity verification happen?
Check identity before the first interview, then confirm it is the same person at every step after that. Fraud often slips in at the hand-offs: between a recruiter screen and a technical interview, or between the offer and the first day.
| Stage | What to confirm | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Application | The profile is consistent: work history, public footprint, location and contact details line up | Catches obvious fakes cheaply, before anyone spends interview time |
| Before the first interview | A government-issued ID is valid and matches a live image of the person | Stops a stand-in or deepfake from entering the process at all |
| Each interview | The person on camera matches the verified person, and stays the same across rounds | Proxy interviews often happen in one round only, usually the technical one |
| Offer | Work eligibility, background and references are checked against the verified identity | Ties every other check to the same confirmed person |
| First day and first weeks | The person who logs in is the person you verified, working from where they said | Catches swaps after the offer and hidden locations |
For remote roles, the first day deserves more attention than it usually gets. Confirm identity again on a live call before granting access to systems. Ship equipment only to an address that matches the verified identity, and question last-minute changes to that address.
What should a candidate identity check include?
A solid pre-employment identity verification process answers three questions. Is this document real? Is the person holding it the person in the document? Does the rest of their story fit that identity?
- Document check. Validate a government-issued ID for signs of tampering, expiry or a mismatch between fields.
- Live match. Compare the ID photo to a live image of the person. Liveness detection checks that the image comes from a real person on camera, not a photo, recording or deepfake.
- Consistency check. Confirm that the verified name lines up with work history, education, certifications and references. For technical roles, real work leaves a trail. A code history, published work or past clients who can be reached through their own company switchboard all help.
- Human review. Have a trained person review anything flagged. Automated tools make mistakes in both directions.
- The same check for everyone. Apply one process to every candidate for a role. Checking only the candidates a recruiter feels unsure about invites bias and misses the convincing fakes.
What identity checks cannot do
Be honest with your team about the limits:
- They confirm identity, not ability. A real person can still overstate their skills. Pair identity checks with skills checks and resume fraud checks. See our guide to resume fraud detection.
- They can wrongly flag real people. Unfamiliar foreign documents, poor cameras and name changes all cause false flags. Give candidates a clear way to resolve them.
- They are a point in time. A check at the offer does not prove who logs in three months later. Re-check at key moments, such as a new project or new system access.
- They collect sensitive data. Face images and ID scans need strong protection, clear consent and short retention. See the Canada and US section below.
What should you do when something does not add up?
Decide your response before you need it. Most teams that run into identity fraud have no plan, so a recruiter either ignores the doubt or confronts the candidate without facts.
Warning signs worth pausing on include:
- The person on camera looks or sounds different from an earlier round.
- The candidate avoids turning on video, or video drops whenever identity comes up.
- The location they claim does not fit the time zone they work in, their phone number or where they want equipment sent.
- Several references share contact details or reply in the same style.
- Requests to change the payment account or shipping address arrive right after the offer.
None of these proves fraud on its own. Each is a reason to verify again, not to accuse.
A simple response plan:
- Pause, do not confront. Pause the process and tell the candidate a standard step is needed.
- Re-verify. Repeat the identity check live, with a trained reviewer.
- Escalate. Send confirmed concerns to security and legal, not just HR.
- Record it. Log what happened, what you checked and what you decided.
- Report it. In the US, the FBI asks companies to report suspected deepfake or stolen-identity applications to IC3, with details such as IP addresses, email addresses and names used.
What changes when hiring in Canada versus the US?
The goal is the same in both countries. The rules on how you collect and store identity data are not. This section is a starting point, not legal advice. Check your process with counsel in each province or state where you hire.
In the US, contractors fall outside Form I-9
US employers must complete Form I-9 for employees. USCIS states that an independent contractor is not an employee for Form I-9 purposes, and the business hiring the contractor does not need to complete one. (USCIS)
That creates a gap. The standard employee check does not cover many consultants, so identity verification for contractors is up to you. If you hire contractors directly, decide who confirms identity and work eligibility, and write it into the contract. If you use a staffing firm or marketplace, ask exactly which checks it runs and when.
Some US states also regulate biometric data, such as the face scans used in liveness checks. Illinois is the best-known example, with Texas and Washington among others. (Miller Thomson, 2025)
In Canada, treat biometrics as sensitive
In August 2025, the Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada released guidance for businesses on processing biometrics under PIPEDA. In summary, from law firm analyses of that guidance (Blakes, 2025; BLG, 2025):
- Biometric data is treated as sensitive, and its use needs a clear, documented purpose.
- The use should be necessary, effective and proportionate to the privacy impact.
- An appropriate form of consent is required.
- Matching one person to their own ID is favoured over searching a database to identify someone.
- If you use a vendor, your organization stays accountable for the data.
Québec has its own rules on biometrics, and Alberta and British Columbia have their own private-sector privacy laws. Check the province, not just the federal rules.
How does Augmnt handle identity on candidate profiles?
Augmnt is a marketplace that connects businesses with verified AI, data and tech consultants. Every consultant is checked for resume fraud, skills, work eligibility and background before their candidate profile reaches you.
Those checks only mean something if they are tied to the right person. Here is what Augmnt does today on identity:
- Profile and resume checks. We compare each consultant's resume and profile against external sources to confirm the history belongs to a real person.
- Profile photo. Consultants can add a photo to their profile. It is optional.
- Video interviews. We then hold video interviews with consultants, so our team meets the person behind the candidate profile.
Augmnt does not check government-issued ID or run a live match. Treat our checks as a first filter on candidate profiles, not a confirmed identity. Before an offer, and especially for roles with access to sensitive systems or data, run your own document check and live match, as described in the table above.
There are two ways to work with us:
- The Augmnt platform. Search and match with verified candidate profiles, with integrations for the applicant tracking system your team already uses. See our ATS integrations.
- Staff augmentation. Our team sources, verifies and delivers onshore consultants in the US and Canada.
No check removes all risk. Our checks give your team a screened starting point, so you can focus your own identity checks where they matter most: before interviews and at the offer.
Frequently asked questions
What is candidate identity verification?
It is the process of confirming that a job candidate is a real person who is who they claim to be. It usually combines a government ID check, a live match between the ID and the person, and a check that their history fits that identity.
Why is identity verification needed in hiring?
Remote hiring makes it easier to apply under a false or stolen identity. The FBI and the US Department of Justice have both documented cases of people using stolen or fake identities to get remote IT jobs with access to company systems and data.
How is identity verification different from a background check?
A background check looks at a person's history, such as criminal records or past employment. Identity verification confirms that the history belongs to the person in front of you. Without it, a background check can come back clean for the wrong person.
Do contractors and consultants need identity verification?
Yes, often more than employees. In the US, independent contractors fall outside the Form I-9 process, so the standard employee check may not happen at all. Agree in writing who verifies a contractor's identity and work eligibility.
What is liveness detection in hiring?
Liveness detection checks that an image comes from a real person on camera at that moment, not a photo, a recording or a deepfake. It is usually paired with a match against the person's ID.
How do employers verify a candidate's identity remotely?
Most remote checks ask the candidate to photograph a government-issued ID and take a live selfie or short video. Software checks the document and compares the two images, and a trained reviewer looks at anything flagged. The identity is then confirmed again on live video at each interview and on the first day.
Can identity verification stop proxy and deepfake interviews?
It makes them much harder, especially when identity is re-checked at each interview and on the first day. It does not replace good interview design. See our guides to proxy interview detection and deepfake interview detection.
Sources
- FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center: Deepfakes and Stolen PII Utilized to Apply for Remote Work Positions (June 28, 2022)
- US Department of Justice: Coordinated, Nationwide Actions to Combat North Korean Remote IT Workers' Illicit Revenue Generation Schemes (June 30, 2025, updated July 3, 2025)
- Gartner: Survey Shows Just 26% of Job Applicants Trust AI Will Fairly Evaluate Them (July 31, 2025)
- USCIS: Form I-9 Exceptions
- Blakes: New Federal Privacy Commissioner Guidance on Processing Biometric Data in the Private Sector (August 2025)
- BLG: Privacy Commissioner of Canada's New Guidance on Biometrics (September 2025)
- Miller Thomson: Biometric Data in Canada (September 2025)
